What drives a seemingly normal couple to kidnap, torture, and enslave a young woman for seven years? The story of Colleen Stan—known as "The Girl in the Box"—takes us into the darkest corners of psychological manipulation and human endurance.

Behind flawless smiles and picture-perfect appearances lurked two of Canada's most notorious killers. In this gripping episode, we peel back the layers on Paul Bernardo and Carla Homolka – the infamous "Ken and Barbie Killers" who terrorized On...

The conclusion of our Monsters of the Moors trilogy delivers the final chapter in one of Britain's most notorious murder cases. After terrorizing Manchester for years, Myra Hindley and Ian Brady's murderous partnership finally came crashing dow...

A seemingly ordinary couple hiding unimaginable evil – this deep dive into the Moors Murders continues with the chilling progression of Ian Brady and Myra Hindley's killing spree across Manchester in the mid-1960s.We track the disappear...

The names Ian Brady and Myra Hindley still evoke horror across Britain decades later. Dubbed the Moors Murderers, this couple's crimes stand among the most reviled in criminal history, with Brady becoming the most hated man in the UK and Hindle...

Few criminal cases have captured America's attention like the saga of Casey Anthony. When two-year-old Caylee Anthony disappeared in the summer of 2008, no one could have predicted the shocking revelation that her mother had waited 31 days to r...

A young woman's dream of capturing America's beauty through van life adventures became the country's most followed missing person case when she never returned home. Twenty-two-year-old Gabby Petito seemed to have it all – artistic talent, a gro...

In this gripping episode, we plunge into the murky waters of the Bernie Tita case, a true crime that intertwines kindness and betrayal. Bernie was once a beloved mortician in Carthage, Texas, whose warm heart and good deeds earned him the town’...

Get ready for an episode filled with laughter, chilling tales, and delicious drinks as we explore the complex themes of true crime intertwined with personal anecdotes. Over some refreshing apple pie moonshine, we dive deep into the sinister wor...

A nice drink from Halpatters while reminiscing about the quirks of Lake City.  We share our appreciation for the comedic brilliance of TikTok creator DanteElizabethJames, we also indulge in some local history, karaoke memories, and a bit o...

Aldi seltzer and Crown Apple is the drinks of choic  this episode.  Our Valentine's Day dinner took an unexpected turn, reminding us of how our bodies are evolving with age – a theme that runs throughout our lively discussions.

Need a unforgettable Valentine's Day with a simple dinner at Red Lobster that turns into a comedy of errors? We sure do, and it's all here—starting with those delicious yet infamous biscuits that caused some unexpected digestive dilemmas. Add i...

Sipping a nostalgic blend of Blackberry White Claw and Galaxy Celsius as you slip into a 90s vibe with a Nirvana shirt and fishnets. This episode kicks off with a fun beverage chat, setting the tone for a trip down memory lane with rave and gru...

Join us as we kick back with our favorite drinks and take a leisurely stroll through Kanapaha Botanical Gardens, all while reflecting on the month that seemed to last forever—January. From there, we jump into discussions about our favorite podc...

 As we sip on our favorite concoctions—a mango White Claw with a twist of Crown shots and a watermelon White Claw—we tackle this shocking story  and much more. We start off with a spirited chat about our weekend antics, family gatheri...

What happens when a casual conversation about seltzers spirals into a harrowing tale of crime and betrayal? We kick things off sipping our favorite drinks of the moment—Jesse with a tropical-flavored Celsius energy drink with crown apple and Li...

Ever wonder how a former military man transformed into one of music's most legendary icons? Join us as we enjoy a Friday with bourbon and White Claw, unraveling the profound legacy of Johnny Cash. From his poignant lyrics to his rebellious adve...

Battling a pesky cold didn't stop us from bringing you laughter and warm stories about our recent escapades. Rather amusingly, Florida's unexpected chill had us bundling up for errands like we were bracing for a blizzard, but it gave us a chanc...

What happens when a small town in Florida becomes the focal point of an apocalyptic belief system? Join us as we unravel the story of Mead Ministries, a cult that transformed Lake City into its sanctuary under the leadership of the enigmatic Ch...

 Picture this: we're sipping on some festive drinks, including a small batch Rebel Kentucky straight bourbon and a unique Bloody Mary mix with an unexpected twist of pickle juices, all while adorned in our coziest Christmas sweaters. We ta...

What kind of birthday celebration pairs perfectly with a spooky Friday the 13th? Join us as we raise a toast to Jesse's birthday with a unique mix of mystery, merriment, and a little bit of mayhem. We're diving headfirst into the astonishing ca...

What happens when a mother's mental health struggles lead her down a path of unimaginable tragedy? We explore the heart-wrenching story of Jessica McCarty, whose battle with postpartum depression and bipolar disorder culminated in a devastating...

What happens when Hollywood takes on real-life horror stories? Join us as we sip on our favorite drinks—Captain Morgan and Dr Pepper for Lindsey, peach White Claw for me—and navigate the chilling waters of "An American Crime." A conversation th...